Frye Men's Engineer 12R Boot

I love these boots. However, I didn't listen to others who have said these boots run large. SO... I ordered my regular size 9.5, then sent em right back and got the size 9. The Amazon seller, Mind Boggler, was really great in communications, being helpful with the return/exchange, etc.- BTW. I guess these boots come in a "regular" width, and a wider version. I have a reasonably "normal" width foot- I'm guessing more or less a "D" width. The size 9 boots are (also as previously mentioned by other reviewers) a tight fit. I couldn't get into them initially- tight across the top of my feet. I have high arches. I'm not certain that has anything to do with the tightness, but thought I'd mention it. I actually took the boots to a local shoe repair guy who stretched them for a few days. They still go on a little tight, but they feel great and I'm sure the boots will relax somewhat and break in to fit my foot really well. I look forward to many years of comfort and protection from the Frye Engineer 12R boot. One other bonus that's worth mentioning:These particular boots are Made In The USA. Not all of today's Frye boots are, but several of their original boots are still bench crafted right here in the USA. PAY HEED TO THE SIZING issues. But by all means, if this is the style of boot you're looking for, it's worth the cost to buy the Frye.

These are my 2d pair of Frye boots, the other being a pair of their Harness 12R model. I have traditionally worn Chippewa engineer boots, as that company was the original manufacturer of this style of boot (specifically their steel toe #27863 model.) Unfortunately, my last pair of Chippewa's had some issues with squeaky soles and an overly snug toe cap that no amount of breaking in and several visits to my cobbler couldn't resolve. So I finally decided to replace them with these Frye engineer boots. Out of the box, they are extremely comfortable. Very nice fitting boots that should break in quickly. These boots retain the classic engineer look that has been around for decades. Some differences I notice from those made by Chippewa: Frye doesn't offer a steel toe option, their boot shaft is also about an inch plus shorter than those made by Chippewa, the leather doesn't seem quite as thick as the "Black Odessa" type used by Chippewa, and the Frye boots seem substantially lighter in weight.

Good boots, well made, look good. I have one issue that I am hoping it will go away. The left foot only feels tight, the length is good but feels tight, since it is real leather I am hoping it will loosen up. The right foot is perfect. I thought it is me, but I do not have this problem with any other boot/shoe; thinking of Frye Smith Engineer boot possibly in a few month.

I simply LOVE these boots. I have been wearing Fryes since my college days in the '70s and have never been disappointed. The craftmanship is Outstanding and unmatched by any other boot. Be forewarned, however, they, like ALL Fryes, need a reasonable breakin time. At first they seem too fit, however, with breakin they fit like a glove and although they are heavy are SO COMFORTABLE. If you are looking for an OUTSTANDING Engineer Boot that is a little pricey, a bit heavy, and require a real breakin these are unrivaled. When it comes to boots Fryes are in a leaque of their own; simply the BEST. PS I suggest before wearing them rub them with a good leather conditioner, such as the one Frye sells, then wear them around the house for several days. I also like to give them a good coat of polish before I wear them outside for the first time. If you never owned a pair of Fryes, you owe it to yourself to get a pair; you deserve them.

Sent a half size larger than ordered. The boots were clearly used. The leather was sratched and worn. The leather was also creased from use. Unbelievable fail. Returned immediately.

Good leather and good craftsmanship. Boot runs one full size large. Boots weight about 4.5 lbs, very heavy boots, no cushion on the inside sole, good to wear for a short period of time, they get uncomfortable after a short period of time.

Not an even cut on rounded sole, left has more material than right,

These things are awesome. I'm wearing them right now, in fact. It's a little rainy today and they're perfect for that. I originally bought a pair of Frye shoes and was so impressed with them that I bought these without hesitation. The sizing is RELIABLE, but maybe not 100% standard. These fit exactly the way my Frye shoes did. So if you own Frye shoes that fit well, you're all set. Order with confidence. That being said, I order my Frye footwear a half-size smaller than most other footwear. For example, my Merrill hiking boots and Puma driving shoes are 10.5s, but I got a 10 for these Frye boots and my other Frye shoes. Anyway, the leather quality is awesome. I've already gotten compliments on them. They feel great. You get what you pay for!

I heard reviewers say it fits as other brands. Hope you know your size well. Other than I ordered too small that was the only gripe. I can’t wait to get my refund so I can order the right size! They were awesome!

Best boots on the market. No other company is able to make sturdy boots like these. A must for those who are looking for serious boots.

Superlative heavy boot in fabulous-quality thick leather, look fantastic with jeans ... The last is normal to narrow, which is a fine thing with an engineer boot. The wide shaft, however, may not be to everyone's taste, and it certainly does not offer the pleasant tight fit of a cowboy or harness boot (a fact which applies to most engineer boots). Wearing them under tight- or even slim-fitting jeans may be a problem, too. These boots are certainly the best choice for the urban wearer who has always wanted an engineer boot but hesitated about clumsy detailing, their soles are relatively slim and the toes rounded, but not bulbous. A great, classic boot.

Hab zwar wieder mit diesen Schwarzen ein Schnäppchen geschlagen, doch hab ich mit diesem Kauf keine 2.Wahl gekauft. Wie bereits vor 2 Jahren bei meinen Braunen, gefällt mir die Verarbeitung für angebliche 375,-€ laut Frye überhaupt nicht. Die Nähte an der hinteren Lasche sind sehr schlecht vernäht und vor allem scheuern diese überstehenden harten Enden an der Wade. Der Stiefel ist aber unverwüstlich und nach 2 Jahren fast täglich sind meine Braunen immer noch im guten Zustand, daher nur - bleib ich bei der Firma, allerdings nur wenn gerade mal über 50% Rabat drin sind, denn dann ist der Preis auch O.K.

All about quality here , very well made boots, you can tell you made the right choice buying as soon as you open the box, I will be wearing these for many years , size wise they fit about half a size too big , I have fitted insoles to compensate for this. I am a 10UK I think a 9.5 UK in this boot would be a perfect fit ! Colour is great not as red as they look in the decribution picture ! 👍